The greatest among you will be your servant. Matthew 23:11

At First Christian Church, we embrace the call of God in the lives of all, regardless of gender, life experience, or background.

Both ministers and lay persons lead in worship, service and spiritual growth. We affirm the ministry of all believers, rejoicing in the gifts of the Holy Spirit—including the gift of leadership—that God has given for the common good. We embrace the opportunity within our congregations to share experiences and perspectives, learn from each other, and find ways to live out our faith in community.

Ministerial Leadership

Rev. Darla Goodrich

Pastor Darla (she/her) was called to FCC in August 2016. She is a graduate of Texas Christian University (BS) and Eden Theological Seminary (MDiv). Rev. Goodrich was ordained in St. Louis where she served congregations of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ). She has traveled with Disciples delegations to post-war Bosnia, South Africa, Lesotho, and South India.

Rev. Goodrich is married to Mark Frank and has four children, Kara, Brant, Megan, and Jamie. She enjoys running, hiking, camping, yoga, oil painting, reading, meditation, and most of all, being with her family.

Rev. Kevin Toth

Pastor Kevin (he/him) was called to FCC in August 2020. He is a graduate of Barton College (BA) and Brite Divinity School at Texas Christian University (MDiv). Rev. Toth was ordained in Raleigh and has interned at three congregations working with youth and leading worship. Rev. Toth has extensive experience directing and counseling at camps and previously worked as a hospital chaplain for two years before transitioning to congregational ministry. Rev. Toth is passionate about spiritual care and loves being a spiritual companion on people's life journeys.

He enjoys nature walks, reading, meditation, video games, writing, and activities that allow him to be a big nerd.

Music Ministry Team

Dr. Juan Hernández

Juan Hernández (he/him) embarked on his musical journey in his native Colombia, where his early studies spanned a variety of instruments and ignited a passion for woodwinds. He earned his Doctor of Music (DM) and Master of Music (MM) in Choral Conducting from the Indiana University Jacobs School of Music, and his Bachelor of Music (BM) in Choral Conducting from Los Andes University in Bogotá.

Juan's experience includes serving as Director of Music Ministries at St. Paul's United Methodist Church in Albuquerque and Westminster Presbyterian Church in Odessa. He also boasts an extensive teaching background, with positions at the University of New Mexico, Odessa College, and Cavazos Elementary. Most recently, he took on the role of Glee Club director at Wabash College.

Outside of his professional life, Juan enjoys spending time with his husband Kevin and their many pets—three dogs and two cats, drinking coffee, walking in nature, engaging in arts and crafts, and playing musical instruments whenever he gets a chance.

Juan joined our staff in August 2024 and is excited to be part of a church community that values each individual's uniqueness and fosters an environment of respect, love, and acceptance.

Tom Lowe

What a joy it is to welcome FCC’s new organist! Tom (he, him) is married to Dianne, has two grown daughters, Mary and Elizabeth, and 5 grandchildren. Raised in Terre Haute, he attended St. Stephen’s Episcopal Church growing up. As a college student at Indiana State University, he majored in Music Education (Choral & General) with his principal instrument being the organ. For over four decades, he has played the organ and piano in Methodist, Lutheran, Episcopal, Baptist, and Roman Catholic congregations. We are so grateful for his beautiful creations each week and the spirit he brings to his playing.

Media Ministry Team

Vic Lindsay

Vic (he/him) began working at FCC in the fall of 2020 when his family moved to Crawfordsville. Vic is a higher education, student affairs professional currently serving as the Coordinator of Student Success at Wabash College where he supports a diverse portfolio of student organizations and activities. On Sundays, Vic assists with worship by operating the video live-stream and directing production. He enjoys traveling and exploring Indiana with his wife and two daughters, as well as all things related to comic books and soccer.

Dale Petrie

Dale has been a member of FCC for 25 years. When the pandemic began in 2020, he worked tirelessly to upgrade our media technology and partners with our media technician each Sunday to make online worship possible. Dale graduated from Wabash College with a bachelor’s in economics and worked 40 years at the Manufacturing Management Steel and Wire Fabrication. Currently he is the Director of Operations for the City of Crawfordsville. In addition, Dale volunteers his time in the church choir and as property chair. He also serves on the Hand and Hand Creative Learning daycare board, Crawfordsville Strawberry Festival, Taste of Montgomery County, and Lew Wallace Museum Board. In his spare time, he enjoys bicycling, traveling, and spending time with his wife, Linda Petrie, children Erin, Daniel, and Emily (Daughter in law), and grandchildren, Graham and Fletcher.

Church Administrative Staff

Crystal Hahnstadt

Crystal (she/her) and her family joined the church in October 2023, and she joined the church staff in January 2024 as Communications Administrator. She holds a Bachelor of Arts Degree in General Studies from Eastern Illinois University, and and Associate of Applied Science Degree in IT Computer Applications and a Certificate in Web Page Design from Lake Land College. She is married to her husband, Peter, and they have two children, Gideon and Laurel. In addition to her duties on church staff, Crystal is a stay-at-home mother and homeschooling her two children. In her free time, she is an avid reader and enjoys spending time with her family and friends.

Andrew Nicodemus

Andrew (he/him) began working at FCC in July 2018 as the Co-Treasurer and transitioned to Financial Administrator in February 2019. He holds a Bachelor of Arts Degree in Accounting from Manchester College and also works as a field examiner for the Indiana State Board of Accounts. In addition, he volunteers as the financial administrator for Hand in Hand Creative Learning daycare. He is also married to his wife, Sara, and has one child, Anders. In his spare time, he enjoys working in the yard, going to Disney World with family, and spending time with Sara, Andres, and the rest of his family.

Kay Nannet

Kay Nannet (she/her) has been an active member of FCC since 1991, and has served as committee chairs, deacon, elder, youth leader, children’s church leader, and Worship leader over the years. Recently she moved to Lafayette, IN and is enjoying being part of a new community. For fun she likes to read, walk, hike, laugh, play games, listen to music, travel, and spend time with friends.

Kay is committed to serving God, FCC, and our community through this position.

Arleen Wilhite

Arleen (she/her) is a lifetime member of First Christian Church and has been volunteering full time in the church office since 2016. She graduated from Crawfordsville High School and previously worked as a registration clerk at Franciscan Health emergency room before retiring in 2015. Arleen has four children, all of whom live throughout Indiana. She enjoys knitting, reading the Bible, visiting family and friends, and serving the church any way she can.

_____________________________________

Kym Bushong

Keeper of the House (not pictured)

Maisie

Always ready to greet you with a smile, Maisie loves to practice her gift of hospitality. In her spare time, she chews on toys, sneaks treats from the office volunteers, and snuggles with Kay, her mom.